News

SERAP drags FG to ECOWAS court over Nigeria’s phone-tapping rules amid privacy row

Share on
0
SERAP files suit against FG at ECOWAS court seeking to scrap Nigeria’s communications interception rules.
Socio-Economic Rights and Accountability Project drags FG to ECOWAS Community Court of Justice over Nigeria’s phone-tapping rules amid privacy dispute.
  • The Socio-Economic Rights and Accountability Project (SERAP) has sued the Nigerian government at the ECOWAS Community Court of Justice over alleged unlawful mass phone surveillance
  • The lawsuit challenges the Lawful Interception of Communications Regulations, 2019 (LICR 2019), which allows telecom operators to install systems enabling security agencies to monitor calls, texts, emails, data, and browsing activity
  • SERAP says the regulations violate Nigerians’ constitutional and international rights to privacy and freedom of expression

The Socio-Economic Rights and Accountability Project (SERAP) has filed a lawsuit against the government of President Bola Tinubu at the ECOWAS Community Court of Justice over what it described as the government’s failure to withdraw “unlawful mass phone-tapping rules” contained in the Lawful Interception of Communications Regulations, 2019 (LICR 2019).

The regulations allow telecommunications licensees to install technologies that enable security agencies to monitor communications such as voice calls, data, text messages, emails and browsing activities for national security and crime-fighting purposes.

In a statement issued on Sunday, March 8, and signed by SERAP Deputy Director, Kolawole Oluwadare, the organisation said the lawsuit was prompted by allegations made by former Kaduna State governor Nasir El-Rufai that the phone conversation of the National Security Adviser, Nuhu Ribadu, had been intercepted.

El-Rufai reportedly claimed, “The NSA’s call was tapped. They do that to our calls too, and we heard him saying they should arrest me.”

The suit, marked ECW/CCJ/APP/11/26, was filed last Friday, March 6, at the regional court in Abuja. SERAP is asking the court for “a declaration that the failure of the government to withdraw the Interception of Communications Regulations is unlawful and a violation of Nigeria’s international human rights obligations.”

The organisation is also requesting the court to declare that the government’s refusal to repeal the regulations “constitutes an official endorsement of unlawful mass phone-tapping rules, as the Regulations are patently unlawful, and violate the rule of law, democratic principles, and the right to privacy.”

SERAP further asked the court to issue “an order directing and compelling the Nigerian government to immediately withdraw the Interception of Communications Regulations, and to commence a legislative process to ensure that any interception regulations are in conformity with Nigeria’s international human rights obligations.”

The case was filed on behalf of SERAP by its lawyers Kolawole Oluwadare, Oluwakemi Oni, Valentina Adegoke, and Maryam Mumuni, who argued that “the Regulations establish a sweeping mass phone-tapping regime that violates Nigerians’ constitutionally and internationally guaranteed human rights, including to privacy and freedom of expression.”

They added, “Where powers affecting fundamental human rights are exercised in secrecy and concentrated in political authorities without independent supervision, the risks of arbitrariness are substantial.

“Surveillance measures that lack strict necessity, proportionality and independent judicial oversight can easily be weaponised against political opponents, journalists, civil society actors and election observers.”

SERAP also warned that the regulations raise concerns as Nigeria moves closer to the 2027 general elections, noting that extensive interception powers could potentially be abused during politically sensitive periods.

The organisation stated, “In an electoral climate, even the perception that private communications are being monitored can chill political organising, investigative reporting and voter mobilisation.

“Free and fair elections depend on confidential communications, protected journalistic sources and open democratic debate. Any misuse of intercepted data for intimidation, political advantage or disinformation would fundamentally undermine Nigerians’ right to political participation and electoral integrity.

“As 2027 approaches, interception powers must be narrowly defined, subject to prior independent judicial authorisation and backed by effective remedies. Without robust safeguards, these Regulations risk threatening privacy rights, freedom of expression and the credibility of Nigeria’s democratic process.”

SERAP maintained that any restriction on privacy rights must comply with the principles of legality, necessity and proportionality, arguing that the regulations fail to meet those standards.

The organisation also cited the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, which has stated that mass surveillance programmes based on indiscriminate and blanket data collection are arbitrary and cannot satisfy the requirements of legality, necessity and proportionality.

According to SERAP, the Nigerian government has a responsibility to introduce clear laws, safeguards, independent oversight mechanisms and accessible remedies to prevent abuse by state agencies and private actors, including telecommunications companies and technology firms.

The group noted that the Nigerian Communications Commission introduced the Lawful Interception of Communications Regulations, 2019 while exercising its authority under Section 70 of the Nigerian Communications Act, 2003.

SERAP argued that Regulation 4 grants broad discretionary interception powers to the National Security Adviser and the State Security Service, without clearly defining the scope or limits of those powers.

It also highlighted inconsistencies within the regulations. 

While Regulations 4 and 12 restrict interception powers to the NSA and the SSS, Regulation 23 broadens the list of authorised agencies to include the Nigeria Police Force, National Intelligence Agency, Economic and Financial Crimes Commission, National Drug Law Enforcement Agency, and any other body that may be designated by the commission.

SERAP said this inconsistency undermines legal certainty and increases the risk of arbitrary use of interception powers.

The organisation also criticised provisions that allow communications interception without a warrant in certain situations, describing them as overly broad and prone to abuse.

It further expressed concern that the regulations do not require authorities to inform individuals who have been subjected to surveillance, arguing that this weakens citizens’ ability to challenge unlawful monitoring.

SERAP added that rules compelling telecommunications companies to install interception equipment and disclose encryption keys could weaken cybersecurity and discourage the use of privacy-protecting technologies.

While acknowledging the government’s duty to tackle national security threats and organised crime, the organisation stressed that such actions must remain within constitutional and international human rights limits.

No date has been fixed for the hearing of the case.

Share on
avatar
Aishat BolajiEditor

Comments ()

Share your thoughts on this post

Loading...

Similar Posts

Never get outdated, subscribe now.

By subscribing, you will get daily, insightful updates of what you need to know in the news, as regarding politics, lifestyle, entertainment and cryptocurrency. You can always cancel it whenever you wish.

Social:

Subscribe now.

Category