- Jamaican singer Buju Banton sparked a controversy after his statement that claimed Afrobeats has no substance
- Many critics opined that his statement came from a place of jealousy
- But could it really be jealousy or a hard truth that Afrobeats fans don't want to swallow?
When controversial comments are made, the first instinct is usually to argue or defend a stance with sentiments. The truth is a hard pill to swallow, wouldn't you agree?
Recently, Buju Banton, a Jamaican reggae legend, stirred controversy online with his comments on Afrobeats during a popular podcast, Drink Champs.
In his words, “When you look at what they (Afrobeats artistes) are doing, their music is not freeing Africa…we desire more from them. You want money? Go get it, but what’s going to be said about you later on? You didn't make any impact. Tell me one Afrobeats song that can uplift us.”
51-year-old Banton argued that Afrobeats, despite its global success, fails to address excruciating societal and political issues, and does not liberate Africans.
In response, critics are quick to point out that the contribution of Afrobeats to the African music industry is incredible as Music in Africa noted that “it is set to top $500 million by 2025.”
The report also submitted that Afrobeats has the potential to create 20 million jobs in the entertainment sector by 2030, making it hard to go. It is indisputable that Afrobeats offers lucrative prospects.
However, considering the depth and substance of Afrobeats songs, I couldn't agree less with Buju Banton’s controversial claim. Yes, I might seem controversial but it is my take. Before you come for me, you should hear me out.
I've read several takes on Banton’s take, from regular social media users to popular critics. I think it is appalling that overzealous Afrobeats enthusiasts attribute Banton’s comments to jealousy rather than look deeper into the statement.
While I may not have agreed with everything he said on the podcast, his criticism of Afrobeats' lyrical depth corroborates with what I believe is gradually fading out in Afrobeats.
I understand that there is a thin line between what an artiste truly wants to sing and what the market demands. Many artistes have probably succumbed to the pressure and commercialisation of Afrobeats and now hardly pay attention to deep songwriting.
Banton, who has collaborated with many international artistes, is totally not jealous of Afrobeats but rather stating the bitter truth. Many Afrobeats artistes, particularly the emerging ones, anchor their songwriting prowess on vices and frivolities. So, the question is, can this stand the test of time?
Nigerian singers’ comments corroborating Buju Banton’s controversial take
Singer Flavour reechoed Banton's comments, saying: “I understand what Buju Banton is trying to say. Kids of today (emerging Afrobeats artistes) don’t want stress; they just want to vibe,”
Following that, Afrobeats singer Omah Lay also shared his thoughts, not directly addressing Banton’s remarks but surprisingly a similar opinion. He said, “I believe people are trying to mess Afrobeats up. I also believe that it is becoming too commercial. Right now, I don't believe Afrobeats are in safe hands.”
Banton’s criticism also revived the genre’s lyrical depth debate earlier voiced by Afrobeats star Burna Boy. In an interview with Apple Music in 2023, Burna Boy criticised the African music/Afrobeats genre for lacking substance with the influx of new artistes. He said, “That’s why you hear most Nigerian music, African music or Afrobeats, as you people call it, is mostly about nothing, absolutely nothing. There is no substance to it, like nobody is talking about anything, its just a great time but at the end of the day, life isn't an amazing time.”
Buju Banton is not jealous of Afrobeats
Buju Banton's criticism on Afrobeats lyrical depth holds water. It is easy to be sentimental and ascribe it to Jealousy but what if we just want to live in denial of the bitter truth?
Yes, Afrobeats’ growth is massive. Yes, artistes are smashing streaming records and topping charts. Yes, it is commercially lucrative, and artistes are making a fortune from it to fund opulent lifestyles. And yes, accolades flood the genre's contribution to the African music industry but are these all there are to Afrobeats?
Yes, the current market demands frivolities and vices as the new taste, but who says Afrobeats artistes cannot set the lyrical standard for the market?
Although this is not to say that all Afrobeats songs lack substance or depth, it is a reminder that music isn't just music for fun but a medium to create a timeless, quality, and remarkable legacy for posterity's sake.
Are female music stars unnecessarily bashed for incorporating Western fashion?
Earlier, TheRadar opined that incorporating Western culture, fashion, and lifestyle had become a significant part of the Afrobeats music scene and the Nigerian showbiz world.
The consequence of this, however, was that critics raised their voices whenever a Nigerian woman chose to follow the trend, especially if they were a celebrity.
