Tech

Binance wins a $6.5bn freezing order over its hack. What it does not change for Nigerian users

Share on
0
Hand holding a smartphone showing cryptocurrency price trends with coins behind it. Illustrative image, not the Binance app or any Binance user.A hand holds a phone showing crypto market prices, with coins in the background. Photo: Alesia Kozik/Pexels. Illustrative image, not the Binance app or any Binance user.

• Binance said on Wednesday 18 November that the Abu Dhabi Global Market Courts had granted it a worldwide freezing order covering up to $6.5 billion against the so far unidentified people behind the 29 October hack of its wallets.

• Reports citing court documents seen by Reuters say the orders tell 18 companies holding frozen hack-linked tokens, Circle and World Liberty Financial among them, to keep those tokens locked, and the court is due to look at the case again on 1 December.

• The order is not a recovery: about $2.85 billion of the roughly $6.34 billion affected had been frozen or intercepted by Binance's own earlier count, and nothing published so far shows any of it has been handed back to the exchange.

A freelancer in Ibadan who gets paid in USDT opens the Binance app, sees the same balance as last week, and still wonders whether the story behind the hack is finished. A trader in Abuja who moved his coins off the exchange in early November is asking a different question: is it settled enough to go back?

This week brought a new chapter, though not an ending. Binance announced on Wednesday that a court in Abu Dhabi had granted it a $6.5 billion worldwide freezing order against the unknown perpetrators of the theft, according to The Block's report on the court order, which says the order was made by Justice William Stone of the Abu Dhabi Global Market (ADGM) Courts. The reports TheRadar read do not agree on the day the order itself was made, so this article dates only the announcement.

A court order aimed at people nobody has named

The defendants in the main order are described only as unidentified persons accused of carrying out the hack. The FBI has attributed the theft to a North Korean group; North Korea has denied involvement. No individual has been named in the Abu Dhabi case.

That is why the mechanics matter more than the headline number. Binance's lawyers at Gibson Dunn say they have compiled a "living list" of 26,000 wallet addresses they believe hold stolen assets, which is updated as the funds move, and that the orders can be served through the blockchain itself rather than on a person at an address.

M. Kendall Day, a partner at the firm, called the injunction "one of, if not the, largest publicly known freezing orders ever made." That is the view of Binance's own counsel, not an independent ranking.

Binance's deputy general counsel, Dugan Bliss, said in the company's statement: "We will continue using every lawful tool available to trace, freeze and recover stolen assets."

Frozen is not the same as returned

The $6.5 billion figure is the ceiling of what the order covers. It is not money in hand. Binance's own earlier figure is that about $2.85 billion of the roughly $6.34 billion affected had been frozen or intercepted by third parties.

The practical value of the Abu Dhabi ruling is in getting that frozen portion released. Binance has said some issuers, exchanges and partners need a formal court order before they will hand anything back. According to an Unchained report citing court documents seen by Reuters, 18 companies are named in the orders, which require them to keep the tokens frozen and bars them from lending, swapping or mixing them with other assets. Circle, which issues USDC, and World Liberty Financial, which is behind the USD1 stablecoin, are among them. None is accused of wrongdoing, and the other 16 have not been publicly named in the reports TheRadar read.

Tether, which says it froze about $1.5 billion of USDT after the hack, is not on that list. Unchained reported Bliss as saying Binance is working out that recovery with Tether directly.

The court is scheduled to return to the matter on 1 December, when, according to Unchained, it will consider whether the injunction over the assets Binance claims as its own stays in force and on what terms. TheRadar found no report of any transfer back to Binance under the order as of Friday 20 November.

The part no court can reach

Stablecoins such as USDT and USDC can be frozen because a company controls them. Bitcoin and ether have no issuer to instruct.

Tom Robinson, co-founder of the blockchain analytics firm Elliptic, told The Block in an earlier interview that about $3.3 billion of the stolen funds remained in bitcoin, ether and XRP, "which no one can freeze." That estimate predates this week's order and comes from one firm, and his remarks are reported by The Block alone. Robinson's point, as The Block reported it, was that tracing still helps investigators flag those coins to exchanges and issuers: "Each time the funds move, there is a chance to catch them."

For a Nigerian who holds most of their savings in dollar stablecoins, there is a quieter lesson in the same facts. The feature that lets an issuer lock stolen tokens is the same feature that makes any stablecoin balance subject to an issuer's decision.

What a Nigerian account holder actually sees

On the app, the ruling itself changes nothing. Binance says it has fully replenished the affected assets and absorbed the loss itself, which on its account means customer balances do not depend on how much is recovered in court. That is the company's own statement, as reported by ITWeb and Khaleej Times; TheRadar could not open Binance's announcement directly. The company's position, in words PYMNTS quoted from its blog post, is that it "will not stop at reimbursing users."

Withdrawals are a separate question. Binance said on 14 November that it had reopened withdrawals on 87 networks that week and aimed to reopen all remaining networks and assets by the end of the following week, as PYMNTS reported alongside the court order. As of Friday 20 November, TheRadar could not find an official statement confirming that every network is now open, so that target should be read as a target.

Nigerian users also remain where they have been since early 2024, when Binance wound down its naira services: there are no naira deposits, withdrawals or naira peer-to-peer trades on the platform. And as TheRadar reported on Monday, the security firm Bitdefender has flagged fake "compensation" emails that ask for a fee. Nothing in the Abu Dhabi order involves payments to individual users.

Binance's own court troubles in Nigeria are untouched by any of this. The federal tax evasion case against the company was adjourned on 9 July to 24 September for a report of settlement or continuation of trial, according to Premium Times, and as of 20 November TheRadar found no published account of what happened on or after that date. A separate $79.5 billion civil claim and an EFCC money laundering prosecution were also pending as of that July report.

The next fixed date is 1 December in Abu Dhabi. The things to watch are whether the freeze is extended, whether any of the 18 companies is ordered to hand tokens over, whether Binance confirms that every withdrawal network is back, and whether the "further independent review" Binance said its initial breach report was subject to is published.

Also read: Binance says it will absorb its $6.3bn hack. What that means for Nigerian users

Also read: Binance lost $6.3bn to North Korean hackers. How a fake job interview let them in

Has the hack changed where you keep your crypto, or are you still on Binance? Tell us in the comments.

Next story · TechGTA 6 has no announced PC or phone version. Security firms say the "downloads" are fakes →Get TheRadar on WhatsAppFollow our channel for the day's main stories, explained.

Spotted an error in this story? Report it. Read our editorial standards.

Share on
avatar
Prince AdeoluwaEditor

Comments ()

Share your thoughts on this post

Loading...

Related stories

Social:

Subscribe now.